ProWritingAid Desktop Review: Features, Pros, and ConsProWritingAid Desktop is a desktop application designed to help writers improve grammar, style, readability, and overall clarity. It combines automated grammar checking with stylistic suggestions, in-depth reports, and integrations aimed at novelists, content writers, students, and business users. This review examines its core features, strengths and weaknesses, workflows, pricing considerations, and how it compares to alternatives.
What ProWritingAid Desktop Does
ProWritingAid Desktop analyzes text and offers corrections and suggestions across multiple categories:
- Grammar and punctuation fixes (spelling, agreement, capitalization).
- Style suggestions (wordiness, passive voice, redundancies).
- Readability improvements (sentence length, transition clarity).
- Repetitive wording, sentence variety, and diction.
- Consistency checks (hyphenation, capitalization, repeated names).
- Writing reports (26+ in-depth diagnostic reports covering pacing, readability, dialogue, overused words, clichés, and more).
The desktop app provides an environment where you can write or paste text, run checks, apply suggestions, and export your edited text. It also stores sessions locally for offline work.
Key Features
- Detailed reports: Over two dozen specialized reports highlight areas for improvement beyond basic grammar — such as structure, sentence length variation, dialogue tags, and pacing for fiction writers.
- Contextual suggestions: The tool offers alternatives and explanations for flagged items so you can choose whether to accept changes.
- Style settings and custom rules: Customize checks based on British vs. American English, genre-specific settings (e.g., creative vs. business), and create custom style rules or banned words lists.
- Integration options: While this review focuses on the desktop app, ProWritingAid integrates with Microsoft Word, Google Docs (via browser extension), Scrivener, and major browsers, letting you use its suggestions across different writing environments.
- Offline capability: The desktop app allows editing without an internet connection — helpful for privacy and when working in places with poor connectivity.
- Batch checking and file support: The app can open and check common file types, including .docx, .rtf, .txt, and others, and lets you export corrected versions.
- Thesaurus and contextual synonyms: Suggests synonym replacements and alternative phrasing.
- User interface: A split view with original text and highlighted suggestions or a live inline editor, plus a sidebar with the list of issues and the reports.
Pros
- Comprehensive analysis: Offers far more in-depth stylistic and structural reports than basic grammar checkers, which is useful for improving writing craft rather than just correcting errors.
- Customization: Allows custom rules and style profiles, making it adaptable to different projects and editorial standards.
- Offline use: Works locally without internet, which benefits privacy-conscious users and those with intermittent connectivity.
- Good value for long-form writing: For novelists and serious writers, the specialized reports (dialogue, overused words, pacing) provide actionable insights not found in many competitors.
- Integrations: Plays well with Word, Scrivener, and browsers, enabling workflow flexibility.
- Helpful explanations: Suggestions often come with clear reasons and examples, which helps users learn and avoid repeating mistakes.
Cons
- Accuracy limits: While strong on style, grammar and contextual understanding can lag behind state-of-the-art competitors in catching complex contextual errors or nuanced phrasing.
- UI learning curve: The rich feature set and many reports can feel overwhelming; new users may need time to learn which reports are most useful.
- Performance on very large files: Some users report slower performance with very large manuscripts or heavy multi-report runs.
- Pricing tiers: Advanced features require a paid subscription; the free tier is limited in daily word counts or feature access compared with fully unlocked competitors.
- Occasional false positives: The tool can flag acceptable stylistic choices as issues — useful for consistency but sometimes noisy if you intentionally vary style.
Who Benefits Most
- Novelists and long-form authors who need pacing, dialogue, and repetition reports.
- Professional writers and editors who want deep-dive analytics to improve craft.
- Students and academic writers who need help with structure and clarity (with attention to citation/style rules outside the tool).
- Content marketers and business writers who value tone, readability, and concision.
Less well-suited for users who:
- Need near-perfect contextual grammar detection for highly technical or legal text.
- Prefer a minimalist, distraction-free editor without many diagnostic reports.
Workflow Example
- Open your manuscript (.docx or .txt) in ProWritingAid Desktop.
- Run a full analysis to generate reports: readability, sticky sentences, overused words, pacing, etc.
- Tackle high-impact issues first (e.g., repeated words, sentence length extremes).
- Use contextual suggestions and thesaurus recommendations to refine awkward phrasing.
- Export the revised document and re-open in your preferred word processor for final formatting.
Pricing Snapshot
ProWritingAid offers a few payment options: monthly, yearly, and lifetime licenses (promotional/offers vary). The desktop app requires a paid plan for unlimited checking and access to all reports; free accounts may be limited in word counts or feature access. Evaluate how often you’ll run full manuscript reports to decide between monthly/yearly vs. lifetime options.
Comparison with Competitors
Feature / Tool | ProWritingAid Desktop | Typical Grammar Checker (e.g., basic tools) | Advanced AI Editors |
---|---|---|---|
Depth of stylistic reports | Extensive (26+) | Limited | Varies; often strong on grammar/context |
Offline desktop use | Yes | Rare | Some do, many are cloud-only |
Custom rules & style | Yes | Minimal | Sometimes available |
Integration (Word/Scrivener) | Yes | Varies | Often integrates with Word/Docs |
Price vs. features | Good for long-form writers | Cheaper or free | Can be pricier with AI features |
Final Verdict
ProWritingAid Desktop is a strong choice for writers who want substantive, actionable feedback on style, structure, and readability beyond simple grammar corrections. Its deep suite of reports and customization options make it particularly valuable for novelists, long-form writers, and editors. If your priority is the absolute best contextual grammar detection or the simplest interface, you may prefer different tools; but for learning-focused, craft-oriented editing, ProWritingAid Desktop delivers excellent value.